OHA - The Ohio Hospital Association

Medical Malpractice Insurance Crisis
A Threat to Patient Access to Health Care

Legislation & Regulation

Tort reform and other legislative or regulatory action are needed on the state and federal level to ensure a stable medical malpractice market in Ohio and across the nation.

Regulations

OAC 3901-1-64
Adopted in 2005, this regulation requires licensed insurers, risk retention groups, self insurers and others offering medical malpractice insurance to submit by May 1 certain information regarding medical liability claims closed during the preceding calendar year.  This rule will enable the department to monitor claims frequency and severity trends in the Ohio market, including the large number of self-insured providers.

OAC 3901-1-65
Adopted in 2006, this regulation requires commercial insurance companies offering medical liability insurance to annually file information with the Ohio Department of Insurance that justifies their rating plan even if the company is not seeking an increase. This rule will enable the Department to ensure that rates are priced appropriately based on recent claims frequency and severity.

 

State Legislation left pending

Senate Bill 88
Introduced:
March 2005
Status: Senate Insurance, Commerce & Labor Committee
OHA position: Support with amendments.
To establish a pilot program mandating arbitration for claims of medical negligence prior to the filing of a complaint.
SB 88 to be Amended (1.27.06)

State Legislation Left Pending in the 125th General Assembly
 

Enacted State Legislation

Senate Bill 80
Enacted:
January 6, 2005
Effective: April  6, 2005
OHA position: Support
A business-backed comprehensive tort reform bill that would establish a punitive damage cap benefiting hospitals.

State Legislation Enacted in the 125th General Assembly

House Bill 66
Introduced:
February 2005
Status: Passed
. Signed by Governor 6/30/05. Effective immediately.
To make operating appropriations for the biennium beginning July 1, 2005 and ending June 30, 2007. Would eliminate hospital exemption of 5-percent tax on annual gross premiums on entities that purchase various types of liability insurance.
Resources: OHA Letter to Rep. Tom Raga
 

 

 

Enacted Federal Legislation
S. 544/H.R. 3205
Patient Safety and Quality Improvement Act
Enacted: July 2005
OHA position: Support
Encourages voluntary reporting of events that adversely affect patients by creating legal and confidentiality protections for patient safety information that providers share for educational purposes.

Pending Federal Legislation
H.R. 2580
Help Efficient, Accessible, Low-Cost, Timely Healthcare (HEALTH) Act of 2007
Introduced: June 6, 2007
Status: Pending in House
OHA position:
Support (also supported by American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists)
Would limit non-economic damages at $250,000, limit the number of years in which a plaintiff can file a medical liability action, and make other reforms to the medical liability system.

S. 243
Medical Care Access Protection (MCAP) Act of 2007
Introduced: January 10, 2007
Status: Pending in Senate
OHA position:
Support (also supported by American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists)
Would limit non-economic damages at $250,000, limit the number of years in which a plaintiff can file a medical liability action, and make other reforms to the medical liability system.

2005-2006 Federal Legislation left pending
2003-2004 Federal Legislation

Resources
OHA Bulletin: 124th General Assembly Enacts Tort Reform

Pending state tort reform legislation as tracked by Columbus law firm Bricker & Eckler, LLP.

Search for state legislation
Search for federal legislation

Questions?
Contact Rick Sites, OHA General Counsel, at ricks@ohanet.org or 614.221.7614.

Back to Medical Malpractice Main Page

© 2001-2008 OHA. Last updated January 03, 2008.
Please direct comments, corrections or additions to: oha@ohanet.org 614.221.7614.